Roddenberry must have had a titanium pair, seriously. I can picture this show's Pilot being pitched:
You see, the Talosians have become dependent on experiences and everything being brought to them through these monitors they sit and watch...great tv show, right? And we are also calling hell a primitive myth on primetime tv. Wha'd'ya say guys?
*Silence*
Did you see the dancing slave girl?
*Cheering*
Maybe that's not exactly how it went, but I like my version.
The Cage feels like a 60s Western or Arthurian Romance. In this case, we have nomadic wanderers of the space frontier and Pike, our head knight errant, has his own code of honor, rescues damsels in distress, and fights villains.
Being made in the early 60s, the bridge is mostly male with an alien thrown in for diversity (apparently there aren't any black/Hispanic people in the future?). Poor Pike also expresses he can't get used to having a woman on the bridge ("I don't think of you like that Lieutenant").
I have 3 big questions from this episode:
1. Are the Talosians really that smart? They can't seem to guess how to put Vina together. It also seems like they could have been a lot cleverer about tricking the captain and the crew. I could have totally done it better with their superpowers.
2. Do people really want freedom and experience more than comfort and illusion? Would we die for it? I know we
say that, but a lot of people are more than happy to spend their weekends watching sports games or
Real Housewives marathons (rather than traveling, building and creating). Maybe we are already in that disturbing future?
3. So slave trader was one of Pike's optional careers, but humans would rather be dead than slaves? Maybe the slaves in his vision don't mind because they're women? That sadly would make sense in the social structure we have been presented with in the show so far.
Fun Fact: Jeremy Bentham wrote "It is the greatest good to the greatest number of people which is the measure of right and wrong." Sounds like Pike when deciding whether to try to rescue the 18 possible survivors while 200 injured were suffering on board his ship. You can
still see Bentham today at University College London...